User blog comment:Popping Marshmallow/I just want to say something about S4 Selection/@comment-25104896-20170320152931

Something I've read a lot by now, and I've been wondering about. Why do all (or a lot) people say that Yume can't be a member of S4 because (aside other reasons, I get it) she isn't a good singer? I understand that Lily and Rola are better singers, but if Yume'd want to become a singer, she wouldn't attend an idol academy. Idols aren't about music but about some-kind of fan-idol relationship. Watch them growing (tho, with a base. Don't pull random girls from the street who can't tell the difference between a piano and a guitar), watch them going through hardship, laugh with (or over) them and meet/talk to them. Lily is definitly not meeting the last part of it. Her weak health is surely preventing her from meeting fans on handshake events, and Rola is lacking the 'watch them grow' part. She was talented from the beginning on, winning everything until Yume had grown a lot and her own struggle started. By now, I'd agree that Rola fits to be part of S4, but not as much as Yume does. Aside of the fact that being MC gives her more spotlight, she had much more idol development than Rola.