Talk:S4/@comment-31586033-20170317051950

Not gunna lie, I'm so glad Lily will not be in S4. She literally had no character development and came in so late to the show. So the possiblitly was low to begin with. Also this stuff about how Yume and Laura wouldn't get close to winning because they didn't "deserve" it was/is absurd. They deserve it way more than a character that came out of nowhere does. Sure her backstory we were told is sad and all, but I don't really care for her. I prefer the characters that were there from the beginning. Who cares if they are first years. Some people are just more talented than others. Age sometimes doesn't  mean much in these types of anime that have to do with talent.

With the way things are going the furture S4 line up for season 2 will most likely be: Ako, Yuzu, Mahiru and Yume. Or, Ako, Yuzu, Mahiru, and Laura.

Either one of them winning will be okay for me. Yume winning is what I want more. Laura's character turned me off in the second episode. She was too prideful and snoby. She grew as the first season went on, which is why I'm fine with her winning if she does.

I'd like to put one theory out there that has been nagging me, though. People are saying Yume shouldn't win the spot in S4 because that wouldn't make sense for the overall story progression throughout the seasons. But, I think it will go perfectly with the vague synopsis we were given for season 2. Yume is facing a "crisis," apparently. What more than her to have achived part of her dream, only to have some other school try to tempt her into joining them while her dream is just starting to become a reality. Her intro say she wants to become a top star, not be in S4 (though that is a childhood dream of hers.) Even more, if Koharu is now attending Venus Ark, that gives them more reasons to tempt her. She doesn't have anything holding her to Four Stars if she doesn't have a commitment to S4. Though, I can be totally wrong. We will see next week who gets into S4, Yume or Laura. If Yume does, I wonder if any of this theory will come true.