Thread:Lucy554/@comment-5138366-20170826183902/@comment-25104896-20170826220235

To bug in, I think a major problem is that no one notices the posts. Unless you're active on the wikia 24/7, you might don't notice a new post. Doing RPs on threads is much easier and more organized. Generally, blog posts are quite diffecult since new users can't really join the RP without having to click a lot.

As well, the story has a way too fast pacing. We more-the-less jumped from episode one (entrance exam) to episode ~7 (first non school audition) to episode 51 (main characters get their self-designed brands and PRs). That's something I indirectly hinted when Erika complained about having to perform with a rare (or higher) coord. Plus, the fact that it, in the end, was more the less a competition of "Who can give his character the more fancy and special thing and make her top idol of top idols" is pretty boring and silly for users who'd like to rp a normal story. That's also the reason why I started the event of SaiEccho and introduced Kanon to be able to compete with the others. Let alone the fact that you literally allowed users to claim that their characters were top idols from the beginning allows 0 development for the user who plays them. As well, and I'll be completly honestly, this is an idol fandom and not a fantasy fandom, so aliens aren't eactly fitting. Some of your blog posts also don't really appeal for RPing; for example the latest. I was thinking about posting something, but I had literally no idea, since my character is still a newbie idol and not a top idol; she can't do anything in the star-thingy and thus would just be hanging around at school.

If you'd want to make it more original, I would treat it as completly different from AikaStars and Aikatsu! (possibly with the brands tho) and put it on a complete new wikia which is solely dedicated to RPing; that'd allow the users to write their characters better and give them more background by posting pages about them, their brands, family and background.

Did you think about simply asking the admins if it's okay to treat the RP like a competition?